I liked the beginning of this book, it was good. The ending was just horrible. I was so sad to see Thorn die, (I mean why?!) I think Erin Hunter could have done much better. And the fact that thorn was killed by his friend is very annoying and sad. There is too much death, as Moon (a baby elephant) gets killed by lions. It’s an okay book, but I expected better.

This is an awesome book. Warriors is the best series I’ve read. Erin Hunter did a good job on this. I do wish Spottedleaf had more time in this book though.

This is a great book (I am currentry waiting for a light in the mist to come out) I would recommend reading all the books in order, if you don’t it won’t make any sense. This book is very interesting.